Border Vigils: Keeping Migrants Out of the Rich World by Jeremy Harding - review

From Global development | The Guardian Fri Nov 16 2012, 17:55:04

Andy Beckett on the troubles of refugees and economic migrants

Near the end of this tightly-coiled, unpredictable book, a border guard invites the author to try scaling a fence. The fence is one of a pair intended to stop illegal immigrants entering Ceuta, the Spanish city surrounded by Morocco which is a favoured way into Europe from Africa. Overcoming this barrier, Harding discovers, "took about 45 seconds. Balancing for the turn at the top, where the only handhold is a straight line of clipped wire, I cut both hands." The guard is unmoved: "[He] said he had watched migrants take both fences in less than 20 seconds."

In an era of footloose capitalism, stark inequality between countries, and ever more information about foreign job possibilities, it is not hard to present the fortifying of national frontiers against immigration as essentially futile. Harding sees restricting migration this way as a "morose task": the European Union, he points out, has a land border of "nearly 9,000km" and a coastline of "another 42,000km". Ingenious people-smugglers and indefatigable would-be migrants talk to him in stranger-than-fiction, concrete detail about their schemes for gatecrashing the rich world. One regular breacher of the Mexican-American desert border endured a three-day, not untypical crossing: "He was flayed below the knees by cacti and when his shoes came to pieces ... he walked the last day barefoot over red rock, a coarse oxidised sandstone ... The soles of each foot [became] a single blister from ball to heel, like a gel pack. [From America] he was deported again... [He made] his next attempt shortly afterwards ..."

Yet apparently doomed government policies can still have large ...

[view whole blog post ]
 See More    |     Report Abuse


You might also be interested in the following news stories:

Tunisia:   Parliament Votes to Dismiss PM Habib Essid (news)
Al Jazeera
31 July 2016

Tunisian Prime Minister Habib Essid has been ousted after overwhelmingly losing a vote of confidence in parliament. In power for a year and a half, Essid's opponents said he had failed to tackle the ... [read more]

Mali:   Govt Extends State of Emergency for Eight Months (news)
Deutsche Welle
31 July 2016

Mali lawmakers have voted to extend a state of emergency until March 2017 due to ongoing violence. The measure allows police to search homes without a warrant, and bans protests. Lawmakers in Mali ... [read more]

Tunisia:   Prime Minister Essid Faces No-Confidence Vote (news)
Al Jazeera
30 July 2016

Members of the Tunisian parliament have gathered to take part in a vote of confidence on the future of Prime Minister Habib Essid, nearly a year and a half after his appointment. Saturday's session is ... [read more]



blogAfrica is allAfrica.com's platform to help you keep an ear on the African blogosphere. We draw diverse voices from around the world who post regularly and insightfully about African issues. Bloggers, submit your blog's rss-feed!