Is federalism the answer?

From Zambian Economist Wed Feb 13 2013, 01:29:00

Delegates at the recently ended Southern Province Constitutional Convention proposed that Zambia adopts a federal system of governance. They amended the Preamble to the first draft constitution, dropping the words "devolved system of governance" and replacing it with the words "federal system of governance". The delegates believe the amendment will allow the local people to "manage their own resources in a more amicable manner".

This will be interesting because PF though Wynter Kabimba have already rejected the idea. The real issue with federalism is - of what sort? Zambia already has some element of federalism because at the basic level federal structures are any structures that exist at two distinct levels - the "central" and "local", each within a well defined scope so that it enjoys autonomy with respect to that scope.

The BIG issue that needs national debate is the degree of federalism that is needed to support social and economic progress in Zambia. Ultimately this is a question about what society we want. The USA federal system is different from the Switzerland or Comoros or Nigeria or Australia. Each country must ask the question - What model of government suits us? Not all issues must be fully devolved. Indeed not all issues are currently devolved, even though we have elements of federalism. Some issues can only be efficiently or fairly handled at the central government level. We need to be clear what those are.

Then there's the question of thinking through some of the negatives. For example, there are huge dangers of large distributional and inequality problems. Under a federal system provinces will compete with one another. That is a good thing but competition of that kind is optimal where there's perfect mobility of people and resources in general. If you find yourself in western province under a corrupt governor heavily influenced by regional politics, you will begin to envy other ...

[view whole blog post ]
 See More    |     Report Abuse


You might also be interested in the following news stories:

Kenya/Comoros:   'Amrouche Spat At No One,' Comoros Boss (news)
Capital FM
30 July 2014

Comoros head coach, Amir Abdou, has trashed charges levelled against his suspended Kenyan counterpart, Adel Amrouche, that he spat at an official during their 2015 Afcon qualifier on May 30. [read more]

Comores:   L'annulation du sommet de la COI provoque des remous (news)
Radio France Internationale
29 July 2014

Les Comores attendent toujours la réponse des quatre autres chefs d'Etats de la Commission de l'océan Indien (COI) à la proposition de fixer un nouveau sommet à la fin du ... [read more]

Comores:   Report du sommet de la COI aux Comores suite au drame d'Air AlgĂ©rie (news)
Radio France Internationale
26 July 2014

Autre conséquence de la catastrophe du vol Air Algérie, c'est l'annulation du 4e sommet des chefs d'Etats de la Commission de l'océan Indien qui devait se tenir ce samedi à ... [read more]



blogAfrica is allAfrica.com's platform to help you keep an ear on the African blogosphere. We draw diverse voices from around the world who post regularly and insightfully about African issues. Bloggers, submit your blog's rss-feed!